Re: Werewolf Rouund 3
Posted: Mon Aug 11, 2008 4:37 pm
Well Dead to be honest.
I thought Amaris was the sage, or the sage didn't actually finger Bitom. You see a sage telling Amaris, and only Amaris they were the sage seemed suicide in my mind, unless they'd scanned her.
However, I did know you and her were talking closely. Alot your PMs both hinted at knowing things that myself or another werewolf had told only you (yes Bit, Grim, and I told each other about every PM any of us received). When Amaris wasn't the sage it seemed likely you were.
I will say I screwed up on day 2 a little, I should have just let Bit die but Tet was throwing out alot of accusations and it made it easy to do the same and basically just confuse the villagers. Also, I think Deadman really did contact me about being suspicious of Tet...he also contacted Grimbold...so I had a pretty good guess he'd contacted others...the nay votes seem to confirm that.
A word of warning if we use PMs again...werewolves can talk about your pms to any of them rather easily.
I will say to many people were swayed by the word of the bodyguard. I was honest when I said Amaris couldn't have any real facts to go on and I was right. She had no proof Deadman was sage, and he had no proof she was a villager. Had she been a werewolf then he'd be a goner. Had the person feeding her information (she never once said it was deadman, she said she was the sage...a lie) been a werewolf the villagers would have lost when they hung Bitom.
I will say I'm surprised I lived, but not that we won. I think Bit and I managed to let Grim stay silent or against us enough that folks would probably have killed each other before him.
I thought Amaris was the sage, or the sage didn't actually finger Bitom. You see a sage telling Amaris, and only Amaris they were the sage seemed suicide in my mind, unless they'd scanned her.
However, I did know you and her were talking closely. Alot your PMs both hinted at knowing things that myself or another werewolf had told only you (yes Bit, Grim, and I told each other about every PM any of us received). When Amaris wasn't the sage it seemed likely you were.
I will say I screwed up on day 2 a little, I should have just let Bit die but Tet was throwing out alot of accusations and it made it easy to do the same and basically just confuse the villagers. Also, I think Deadman really did contact me about being suspicious of Tet...he also contacted Grimbold...so I had a pretty good guess he'd contacted others...the nay votes seem to confirm that.
A word of warning if we use PMs again...werewolves can talk about your pms to any of them rather easily.
I will say to many people were swayed by the word of the bodyguard. I was honest when I said Amaris couldn't have any real facts to go on and I was right. She had no proof Deadman was sage, and he had no proof she was a villager. Had she been a werewolf then he'd be a goner. Had the person feeding her information (she never once said it was deadman, she said she was the sage...a lie) been a werewolf the villagers would have lost when they hung Bitom.
I will say I'm surprised I lived, but not that we won. I think Bit and I managed to let Grim stay silent or against us enough that folks would probably have killed each other before him.